We are dedicated to delivering what we believe is one of the cleanest nail polishes on the market. CMM nail polish does not contain toxic chemicals (like toluene, formaldehyde/formaldehyde resin, dibutyl phthalate (DBP), or camphor) typically found in low-end polishes.


We are passionate about our stance against animal testing and go to great lengths to only do business with vendors that share our love for protecting our furry friends. We make every effort to ensure that our raw materials and ingredients are NOT produced from or tested on animals.


Every CMM decision is based on creating the highest quality product while minimizing our environmental impact. Our minimal packaging for each shipment isn’t fancy, but it’s 100% recyclable–of which 96% is completely biodegradable.

What We Do

Every month we craft one unique shade of premium, boutique quality nail lacquer that is inspired by the natural beauty of the season and leading fashion trends, then deliver it to your door for only…


Who We Are

Color Me Monthly was founded by two sisters, Meghann and Caitlin, with the belief that high-quality doesn’t have to be high-priced. CMM’s mission is to provide environmentally responsible products with the focus on delivering quality ingredients rather than flashy marketing.

  • Crafted with love

    Each month’s polish is crafted with the utmost attention to detail, uncompromising quality standards, and a deep passion for pushing the boundaries of what is creatively possible in the world of nail polish.

  • In-Season & In-Style

    Current season and fashion/color trends are the inspiration for each of our monthly colors. We’ve done the hard work for you. Rest assured, every polish you receive will be timely and fashionable.

  • Free Shipping With Integrity

    When we say free shipping, we mean it. We don’t believe in baiting you with a low sticker price up front only to add fees on the checkout page. We believe in simple honesty. No fine print.

  • Complete Freedom

    No commitments. While we hope you will stay a member forever and ever, if you need to cancel your subscription for any reason you can do so with just a click of a button from the “My Account” page.

What others say about us

I love that the colors really seem to go with the month’s seasonal theme, and come in a wide range of finishes. Also, $7.00 per month for a subscription polish that is delivered to your home is a great deal!

Stephanie -
It is like Christmas every month! I adore these polishes!
Brenda -

I’ve been doing my own nails every week for the better part of two years. Needless to say, I’ve used a wide variety of polishes of varying price and quality. CMM is the *only company* that offers a quality formula *consistently* for a more-than-reasonable price! And the surprise in the mail is always fun. :)

Karla - Maryland

I love the suprise each month. CMM is by far my most favorite polish. It lasts a long time with no chipping or fading. I get colors I would never think I would like….and end up loving!

Amanda - Louisiana

One of the most fun, & affordable sub boxes on the market today, CMM always manages to surprise & delight me with their unique & well-thought-out shades month to month. Not only a HUGE fan of CMM’s varying shades, but their Base & Top coat polishes absolutely extend the life of your manicure, & I should know – Being an artist, & also working PT in pet supply retail, my hands subjected to to a lot of washing, etc. & I’ve yet to experience chipping using the full CMM product experience… I only notice when my nails need a change of color when my nails grow to a noticeable length, or when I’m bored of the color. You will not be disappointed with CMM!

Mary, ME (Mono) Grey -
Color Me Monthly has vibrant and unique colors that last for weeks!!
MissP - North Carolina
I must say that the polishes were simply beautiful! If you’re starting out, this may be a great way to start, and if you’re a hoarder, then this could be for you too! $7/month for a great quality formula and beautiful color is a fantastic deal!
Shipra -
If you aren’t yet subscribed to Color Me Monthly, you gotta jump on the bandwagon because you’re missing out on these gorgeous polishes they specially create for each month.
Krystal -

Ready to become a member?

  • cmm-polish-group-600x600

    Color Me Monthly

    $7.00 / month
  • cmm-polish-group-600x600

    Color Me Yearly

    $75.00 / year
  • cmm-polish-group-600x600

    Color Me Half-Yearly

    $40.00 / 6 months

Shopping for previous colors?

  • cmm-oertels-rose

    Oertel’s Rose

  • cmm-resolve


  • cmm-its-a-wrap

    It’s A Wrap

  • cmm-perkin


  • cmm-poe


  • cmm-second-cup

    Second Cup

  • cmm-perseids


  • cmm-leonardo


  • cmm-revelry


  • cmm-est-1912

    Est 1912

  • cmm-sorcerers-violet

    Sorcerer’s Violet

  • cmm-orla


  • cmm-unconditional


  • cmm-janus


  • cmm-crystal-city

    Crystal City

  • cmm-natures-splendor

    Nature’s Splendor

  • cmm-incantation


  • cmm-daily-grind

    Daily Grind

  • cmm-mango-habanero

    Mango Habanero

  • cmm-south-pacific-450x450

    South Pacific

  • cmm-americana


  • cmm-renewal


  • cmm-pixies-parlour

    Pixie’s Parlour

  • cmm-dublin


  • cmm-champagne-cupcakes

    Champagne & Cupcakes

  • cmm-blustery-day

    Blustery Day


    Roasted Chestnuts


    Just For You

  • Pennywise


  • Annapolis


  • Lemon Battery

    Lemon Battery

  • Panther


  • Candied Clementine

    Candied Clementine

  • Chiffon


  • Sirens


  • cmm-leprechauns-loot

    Leprechaun’s Loot

  • Seven Sisters

    Seven Sisters

  • 14


  • Wrapped in Tinsel

    Wrapped In Tinsel

  • cmm-1982-vintage

    1982 Vintage

  • Alchemist


  • Summer Tryst

    Summer Tryst

  • Monday